School district demands a flood of paper from the residents it sued
First the Austin Independent School District sued its own residents to try to force them to accept a massive luxury apartment in their midst.
Now that Rosedale residents are resisting, AISD lawyers have upped the legal ante: They’re requiring 58 defendants to individually answer a 193-question “discovery” document. That’s more than 11,000 queries in all.
Who’s living with you? And give us your blueprints
The inquiries are both intrusive and long.
Did you build a garage apartment? Then produce blueprints, AISD lawyers have demanded. Did you claim a homestead exemption? Then document it for the past five years. And who lives with you? AISD wants to know that, too, requiring Rosedale residents to list every one of their homes’ occupants.
“Unfortunately this is just the latest step downward in a trajectory of mistreatment by the district toward its constituents,” said Carl Reynolds, who has been monitoring the school situation for the last five years. Reynolds is a leader of both the Rosedale Neighborhood Association and the Play Fair With Rosedale group.
Why all the questions?
Lawyers from Jackson Walker, AISD’s hired law firm, are demanding the answers from 58 residents living near the former Rosedale Elementary School at 49th Street and Ramsey Ave. On Oct. 31, 2025, the district sued nearby residents in an effort to get around 1938 deed restrictions that limit the property’s use. The district has a pending $26 million contract to sell the land to OHT Partners. The Austin-based developer wants to put a six-story, 435-unit apartment building on the 4.3-acre site.
Neighbors have opposed the development as it has been proposed, and negotiated for a smaller development with more affordable housing.
Massive set of questions
The district’s lawyers issued their intrusive, massive document demand shortly after those negotiations fell through in September. The neighborhood is still open to a negotiated settlement that accommodates housing, but not at the massive scale OHT pas proposed.
While information exchanges are routine in lawsuits, and some can get lengthy, the demands from the school district will require defendants to produce a paper avalanche.
Although the district sued 125 residents, only the 58 who participated in the failed negotiations were hit with the massive document demands.

As long as a bar exam
In terms of sheer volume, AISD lawyers are asking almost as many questions as the standard multistate bar exam. Prospective lawyers get six hours to answer its 200 questions.
Put another way, the Rosedale defendants have to answer as many questions as a Texas STAAR test, a Texas driver’s license exam, a U.S. Citizenship test, and an SAT test – back to back to back to back.
The discovery demand documents came in two waves, both delivered to residents in October. Together, the inquiries and their instructions take up 29 legalese-filled, single-spaced pages.
So! Many! Questions!
| Test | Number of questions | Who takes it |
| U.S. Citizenship Civics Test | Up to 20 questions | Naturalization applicants |
| Texas Driver’s Knowledge Test | 30 questions | First-time driver applicants |
| Texas STAAR (Grades 3-8) | ~32 to 52 questions per subject | Texas public school students |
| Scholastic Aptitude (SAT) Test | 98 questions | High schoolers applying to college |
| Texas Real Estate Exam | 125 questions | Prospective Texas real estate agents |
| Rosedale discovery | 193 questions | Rosedale residents who got sued by AISD |
| Multistate Bar Exam | 200 questions | Law school graduates / attorney licensing |
Who’s asking
Jackson Walker LLC, assembled the lengthy set of questions Rosedale residents must answer. The questions fall into three categories:
- Requests for admissions. These are simple statements of fact, which the defendant is asked to admit or deny. There were 145 of those.
- Interrogatories. AISD posed 21 “rogs,” as they’re called in the legal profession. These are closer to essay questions, asking for detailed explanations on topics raised by the lawsuit. They often branch off into multiple subparts.
- Requests for production. These 27 requests demand that defendants provide documents.
Answering them is mandatory: Ignoring the deadline or turning in evasive, incomplete answers carries severe legal consequences, including losing the lawsuit.
Even before answering the questions, residents must plod through six pages of definitions and terms.
Just one definition alone — for the words “identify” and “identification” — requires reading 450 words. That’s roughly the length of two Gettysburg Addresses.
Define ‘and’
Even the words “and” and “or” require explanation:
The document helpfully says, “The words ‘and’ and ‘or’ shall be construed either conjunctively or disjunctively as required by the context to bring within the scope of these discovery requests any response or document that might be deemed outside its scope by another construction.”
Snooping into who you live with
In one of the most intrusive questions in the packet, AISD formally demands that Rosedale residents “identify all residents and occupants of your property since Oct. 31, 2025.” That means the school district is demanding a log of who has been sleeping in your spare bedroom, visiting family members, or house-sitting.
Head-scratcher questions
Some of the questions are head-scratchers.
Request for Admissions No. 86, for instance, asks residents to “admit that you are not a public school district.”

Ample money for lawyers
At its core, the lawsuit is about money. The school district has said it needs to sell the former Rosedale School property to help plug a budget gap, which as of October 2026 stood at an estimated $181 million. It has a pending sales contract to sell the Rosedale School site for $26 million to a developer. OHT Partners, the developer, wants to build a massive 435-unit apartment complex on the site, but the contract requires the district to sweep away the deed restrictions before becoming final.
AISD has annual revenue of $1.48 billion. Its pockets are still deep enough to pay at least $300,000 to outside counsel in the past year up to early October. The defendants have a GoFundMe page.
Back in ’39 …
Reynolds noted that the Rosedale deed restrictions include a procedure for changing them. School officials followed that procedure in 1939 when they wanted land for the school: They went to every homeowner within 200 feet and obtained written permission to build a school on the land.
This time, AISD didn’t ask. It just sued.
“They’ve gone 180 degrees from a principled public approach to the fate of their ‘community assets,’ skipping over the obvious method of gaining consent from the lots within 200 feet, in order to sue dozens of homeowners, and now this expensive gamesmanship by their lawyers,” says Reynolds.
30 days to respond
Rosedale residents were given 30 days to respond. The deadline for answering the last batch of the 193 questions is Nov. 22. Rosedale’s lawyers are expected to object to many of the AISD queries.
The overall case, No. D-1-GN-25-009749 in Travis District Court, does not yet have a court date.
0 Comments